What's the Matter with Helen?

Synopsis

What's the Matter with Helen? is a 1971 psychological thriller starring Debbie Reynolds and Shelley Winters as two former vaudeville performers who relocate to a small Midwestern town to open a dance studio. Haunted by their tragic past and desperate to escape their past mistakes, the women find themselves trapped in a web of suspicion, paranoia, and dark secrets. As tension builds, disturbing events unfold that challenge their friendship and sanity. Directed by Curtis Harrington, the film blends elements of suspense, drama, and horror, showcasing compelling performances that explore themes of guilt, repression, and madness in a stylistic and unsettling narrative.

Cast

• 

  Debbie Reynolds

  Adelle Bruckner

• 

  Shelley Winters

  Helen Hill

• 

  Dennis Weaver

  Lincoln Palmer

• 

  Micheál Mac Liammóir

  Hamilton Starr

• 

  Agnes Moorehead

  Sister Alma

• 

  Helene Winston

  Mrs. Greenbaum

Reviews

Reviews for What's the Matter with Helen? have been mixed, reflecting a range of critical perspectives. On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds a 55% approval rating, indicating a divided response from critics and audiences alike. Some reviewers praise Debbie Reynolds and Shelley Winters for their intense and nuanced performances, noting the film’s stylish direction and atmospheric mood as strong points. For example, some critics highlight the film's effective build-up of psychological tension and its intriguing exploration of complex female characters. However, other reviews point to uneven pacing and melodramatic elements that may detract from the overall impact. IMDb users rate the film at 6.3/10, suggesting moderate appreciation, with viewers often mentioning the film's campy yet captivating qualities. While not universally acclaimed, What's the Matter with Helen? remains a noteworthy entry in the psychological thriller genre of the early 1970s, appreciated for its unique style and strong lead performances.