I Came By

Synopsis

I Came By is a gripping British thriller that follows the lives of a young graffiti artist named Toby, played by George MacKay, who breaks into the homes of the wealthy elite to leave his art as a message. However, Toby's latest target, a mysterious retired judge named Sir Hector Blake, unveils a dark and twisted reality that leads him down a perilous path. As Toby's actions trigger a deadly confrontation, he finds himself entangled in a web of horror, deception, and the quest for justice. The film explores themes of class conflict, moral ambiguity, and the consequences of one's actions. Tension escalates as Toby's close friend, Jodie, played by Percy's mom, and his family become embroiled in a life-or-death struggle against a man hiding sinister secrets. With its chilling atmosphere, unpredictable plot, and sharp social commentary, I Came By delivers an unsettling exploration of how appearance versus reality can shatter lives in unexpected ways.

Cast

• 

  George MacKay

  Toby Nealey

• 

  Percelle Ascott

  Jameel 'Jay' Agassi

• 

  Kelly Macdonald

  Lizzie Nealey

• 

  Varada Sethu

  Naserine 'Naz' Raheem

• 

  Franc Ashman

  DS Ella Lloyd

• 

  Anthony Calf

  Superintendent William Roy

Reviews

Critics have delivered a mixed bag of reviews for I Came By, with some praising its dark thematic elements while others criticize its execution. The film currently holds a 69% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with an average audience score giving it a respectable reception. According to a review from The Guardian, the film is 'an unsettling exploration of privilege and power,' praising MacKay's performance as 'haunting and deeply immersive.' On the other hand, some viewers on IMDb, where the film has a score of 6.2/10, found it to lack cohesion, noting that 'the pacing falters in the second act, leaving some threads unfulfilled.' Metacritic gives it a score of 57/100, highlighting a divide among critics—while some laud director Babak Anvari's bold cinematic approach, others suggest it fails to fully capitalize on its intriguing premise. Despite this, The Independent notes the film’s 'chilling moments that keep the audience on edge,' indicating that many feel the film successfully delivers tension, although it might leave some viewers yearning for deeper narrative richness. Overall, I Came By is noted for its allure and strong performances, especially from MacKay, making it a film worth a watch for fans of psychological thrillers.