Maytime

Synopsis

Maytime is a classic 1937 romantic musical drama featuring Jeanette MacDonald in a captivating dual role. The story weaves through two generations, highlighting a timeless romance set against the backdrop of early 20th-century Manhattan. The plot unfolds as the Paris Opera singer Marcia Mornay and the American composer Richard Wayne fall deeply in love but are separated by unforeseen circumstances. Decades later, their love story is rekindled through their children, blending themes of passion, sacrifice, and the enduring power of music. With lush musical numbers and evocative performances, Maytime explores love’s resilience across time and the lasting impact of heartfelt devotion.

Cast

• 

  Jeanette MacDonald

  Marcia Mornay

• 

  Nelson Eddy

  Paul Allison

• 

  John Barrymore

  Nicolai Nazaroff

• 

  Herman Bing

  August Archipenko

• 

  Tom Brown

  Kip Stuart

• 

  Lynne Carver

  Barbara Roberts

Reviews

Maytime has been warmly embraced by audiences and critics alike, as reflected in its impeccable 100% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and a solid 7.3/10 on IMDb. Critics have praised Jeanette MacDonald’s compelling portrayal, noting her graceful singing and emotive acting that brings depth to this romantic epic. The film’s lush production design and memorable musical score, featuring the iconic title song, have been highlighted for creating an enchanting cinematic experience. However, some contemporary reviewers have pointed out the film’s melodramatic plot elements and somewhat dated pacing, which may not resonate with modern viewers seeking more dynamic storytelling. Nonetheless, the consensus underscores the film’s charm as a quintessential 1930s musical romance, balancing heartfelt emotion with impressive performance. As Variety's review noted, “MacDonald’s voice soars effortlessly in a film that captures the essence of romantic yearning and musical elegance.” Meanwhile, summaries on classic film forums celebrate Maytime’s nostalgic appeal, marking it as a treasured gem for fans of vintage musicals. Overall, this enduring production is recognized for its heartwarming narrative and timeless musicality, securing its place in classic American cinema history.