We Are All in Temporary Liberty

Synopsis

"We Are All in Temporary Liberty" (original title: "Siamo tutti in libertà provvisoria") is a 1971 Italian drama directed by Manlio Scarpelli featuring Riccardo Cucciolla in a leading role. The film delves into the lives of several characters who have recently been released from prison on provisional liberty. As they navigate the complexities of reintegration into society, the narrative explores themes of justice, freedom, and social stigma while shedding light on the challenges faced by individuals trying to reclaim their place in a world that remains wary of them. Beyond its intimate character studies, the film offers a critique of the criminal justice system and the fleeting nature of liberty itself.

Cast

• 

  Riccardo Cucciolla

  Mario De Rossi

• 

  Vittorio De Sica

  Giuseppe Mancini 'Pulcinella'

• 

  Macha Méril

  Gisella, wife of Mario De Rossi

• 

  Bruno Cirino

  Panzacchi

• 

  Philippe Noiret

  Judge Francesco Langellone

• 

  Lionel Stander

  Lawyer Bartoli

Reviews

Overall, "We Are All in Temporary Liberty" has garnered mixed to positive reviews from critics and audiences alike. On IMDb, the film holds a moderate rating of 6.5 out of 10, indicating a generally favorable reception. Critics have praised Riccardo Cucciolla's compelling performance, highlighting his ability to portray the nuanced struggles of a man caught between hope and societal judgement. Reviewers from classic film forums have noted the film's realistic depiction of post-prison life and its social commentary, lauding the director's restrained and contemplative style. However, some critiques focus on the film's pacing and narrative structure, suggesting that it can feel slow or uneven at times, which may affect viewer engagement. While not widely reviewed on major aggregator sites like Rotten Tomatoes or Metacritic due to its age and niche appeal, film historians and enthusiasts appreciate it for its thematic depth and the socio-political context it encapsulates. It remains a significant work in Italian cinema for those interested in stories about justice, freedom, and human resilience.