The Joe Schmo Show

Synopsis

The Joe Schmo Show, hosted by Cat Deeley and released in 2025, is a unique reality television series that parodies the traditional reality show format. In this unconventional and humorous series, one unsuspecting contestant believes they're participating in a genuine reality competition, while all other participants are actors playing scripted roles designed to manipulate and entertain. The show cleverly blends satire, improvisation, and comedy, challenging the notions of reality programming and audience expectations. Throughout the season, viewers are taken on a hilarious and intriguing journey filled with surprising twists and character-driven drama, showcasing both the artifice of television and the genuine reactions of the genuine contestant.

Cast

• 

  Cat Deeley

  Self - Host

• Lisa Fredrickson

  Agnes

• 

  Frances Callier

  Barbara

• 

  Londale Theus Jr.

  Braxton

• 

  Ahamed Weinberg

  Charles Michael

• Jamie Hultgren

  Chastity

Reviews

The Joe Schmo Show has garnered a mixed but generally positive reception from critics and viewers alike. On Rotten Tomatoes, the show holds a fresh rating of 78%, with reviewers praising its innovative concept and sharp satire of reality TV tropes. For example, The Hollywood Reporter lauds the show, stating, "A clever send-up of reality television that keeps viewers laughing while questioning the authenticity of what we watch." Metacritic presents a more mixed score of 65/100, reflecting a range of opinions. Some critics argue that the humor occasionally falls flat or relies too heavily on cringe comedy, which could alienate some audiences. IMDb users have rated the show at 7.4/10, appreciating Cat Deeley's charismatic hosting and the cast's comedic performances, but some point out pacing issues in certain episodes. Overall, The Joe Schmo Show is considered a refreshing twist on the genre, appealing to viewers who enjoy meta-humor and reality show parodies, even if it's not universally acclaimed as flawless entertainment.