With or Without You

Synopsis

With or Without You, originally titled 東坡家事, is a 2015 Hong Kong television drama starring Bobby Au-Yeung and Lydia Shum Tsan-Wah. Set during the Song Dynasty, the series poignantly explores the life of Su Shi, a renowned poet and scholar, focusing on his complex family dynamics and the historical challenges he faces. The drama intricately blends historical facts with human emotions, highlighting themes of loyalty, resilience, and the enduring power of love amidst political turmoil and personal hardship. Through compelling storytelling and strong performances, the show offers a captivating glimpse into an iconic figure's life and legacy.

Cast

• 

  Bobby Au-Yeung Tsan-Wah

  So Tung-po

• 

  Joey Man Yee-Man

  Wong Yun-zhi

• 

  Jimmy Au Shui-Wai

  So Chit

• 

  Harriet Yeung Sze-Man

  So Tai-mui

• 

  Vincent Wong Ho-Shun

  Chun Shiu-yau

• 

  Alice Chan

  Lau Yuet-oh

Reviews

With or Without You has garnered generally positive reviews from both critics and audiences. On IMDb, the show holds a rating of 7.1/10, reflecting a favorable reception for its storytelling and strong acting performances, particularly by Bobby Au-Yeung. Critics have praised its rich historical setting and emotional depth, with some noting the show's ability to humanize historical figures. However, some reviews mention that the pacing can be slow at times, which may not appeal to viewers seeking fast-paced narratives. The Hong Kong media outlet HK01 highlighted the series as "a thoughtful and well-acted historical drama that brings depth to classical characters," while some viewers on Douban gave it mixed ratings citing its traditional approach and occasional melodrama. Overall, With or Without You stands out as a respectful and engaging adaptation that balances historical authenticity with dramatic storytelling.