A Woman is the Judge

Synopsis

A Woman is the Judge is a compelling courtroom drama film released in 1939 that centers on the struggles and triumphs of Anne Graham McNeill, a female judge portrayed by Frieda Inescort. Set in a time when women were rarely seen in positions of judicial authority, Anne must navigate a complex legal system and societal prejudices to deliver justice. The movie showcases her dedication to her career and her moral compass, as she faces challenges both in the courtroom and in her personal life. As Anne strives to balance her professional responsibilities with the expectations placed upon her as a woman, she emerges as a pioneering figure, emphasizing the importance of integrity and resilience in the pursuit of justice. Directed by Nick Grinde, the film juxtaposes the tension of legal proceedings with the emotional depth of its characters, making for a thought-provoking viewing experience.

Cast

• 

  Frieda Inescort

  Mary Cabot

• 

  Otto Kruger

  Steven Graham

• 

  Rochelle Hudson

  Justine West

• 

  Mayo Methot

  Gertie

• 

  Gordon Oliver

  Robert Langley

• 

  Arthur Loft

  Tim Ryan

Reviews

A Woman is the Judge has received a mixed bag of reviews from critics, reflecting both appreciation for its forward-thinking premise and criticism for its narrative execution. According to IMDb, the film holds a rating of 6.4/10, indicating a generally favorable reception. The New York Times praised Frieda Inescort’s performance, noting her 'graceful and commanding presence' that brings a sense of realism and empathy to the role of Anne Graham McNeill. Rotten Tomatoes featured user reviews highlighting the film's progressive take on gender roles, with one reviewer stating, 'For a 1939 film, it daringly tackles the issue of a woman in a male-dominated field with surprising nuance.' However, some critics have pointed out the film's slower pacing and lack of character development in supporting roles. Metacritic users commented on the film’s dated aspects, yet recognized its historical significance, with one review mentioning, 'While some elements feel archaic, the movie’s central theme of gender equality resonates even today.' On the whole, A Woman is the Judge is celebrated for its ahead-of-its-time subject matter and Frieda Inescort's strong performance, despite certain cinematic shortcomings.